/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-expressandstar-mna.s3.amazonaws.com/public/R2M7UEHNJFDJRBB67BFDO2X2OQ.jpg)
The selfie was taken by a solo crested macaque whereas this group posed for a professional
Here's a snapshot of how this monkey business ended up in a federal appellate court: In 2011, photographer David Slater set up his camera in an Indonesian forest, and Naruto, a crested macaque, snapped some photos of himself. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) brought the case acting as Naruto's "next friend", a legal status reserved for someone who acts in court on behalf of another who is unable to do so, usually because of a disability.
The court found that PETA couldn't represent Naruto as a "next friend" because it couldn't establish it had a relationship with the monkey allowing to serve as a legal guardian in a court proceeding and because current law didn't grant animals such legal representation.
The court ruled that Slater was entitled to attorneys' fees in the case and sent it back to the district court to determine the amount. Slater agreed to donate 25 percent of gross revenue from the selling of the monkey selfies to charities advocating for the welfare and protection of the habitat of crested macaques.
"We conclude that this monkey-and all animals, since they are not human-lacks statutory standing under the Copyright Act", the ruling said.
Worse, the court said in a lengthy footnote: "We feel compelled to note that PETA's deficiencies in this regard go beyond its failure to plead a significant relationship with Naruto".
In a separate opinion in the selfie case, 9th Circuit Judge N. Randy Smith called PETA's lawsuit "frivolous" and said he would not have ruled on the merits of the copyright claim, but instead would have dismissed the case on other grounds.
As Courthouse News points out, the three-judge panel's opinion does not address some of the case's potentially more far-reaching issues, such as whether or not a human can own copyrights of images made by animals or machines.
"But now, in the wake of PETA's proposed dismissal, Naruto is left without an advocate, his supposed "friend" having abandoned Naruto's substantive claims in what appears to be an effort to prevent the publication of a decision adverse to PETA's institutional interests", the court said.
At the same time, Kerr said the decision would not affect the settlement.
"It is clear: PETA's real motivation, in this case, was to advance its own interests, not Naruto's".
Smith adds that PETA also used Naruto as a "pawn to be manipulated on a chessboard larger than his own case".
Recommended News
-
Indian court rules self-styled 'godman' guilty of raping 16-year-old
The victim in the case for which Sirumalani was jailed, as well as her family, had been followers of the guru for almost a decade. Over the last four years, since the trial began, as many as nine witnesses in the two cases have been attacked.Tim Cook will meet with President Trump later today
President Donald Trump in what is now being described as an effort to prevent a trade war with China. Trump recently announced $50 billion in tariffs on Chinese goods, prompting Beijing to retaliate.Inventor Peter Madsen gets life sentence for Kim Wall murder
At the time of her murder, she was living with her boyfriend near Peter Madsen's workshop in a disused Copenhagen shipyard. Wall, 30, went missing when Madsen took her out to sea in his 17-metre submarine from Copenhagen's harbour. -
Alexis Sanchez fires new dig at Arsenal ahead of Manchester United clash
The Scotland global travelled to America previous year and he says the experience helped him make a key contribution this season. Jose Mourinho helped Scott McTominay on and off the pitch at Manchester United .Gmail's big redesign is rolling out to all on the web
Over on mobile, we'll see two new features geared toward keeping you focused and reducing clutter in your inbox . Additionally, an expiration date can be set to automatically delete the email after the mentioned time interval.Whoever gets to Texas first gets to extradite accused FMB murderer
She had been on the run since allegedly killing her husband, David Riess, in their Blooming Prairie home last month. Authorities said that Riess (left) fatally shot Pamela Hutchinson, 59, in Florida, after befriending her. -
Acadiana plans to take part in National Drug Take Back Day Saturday
The Greenwood Lake Police & Coalition would like to remind residents of National Drug Give Back Day on Sat., Apr. 28. If you can't make it to a take back event, visit www.countitlockitdropit.org to find a drop-off box near you.Rise & Shine: Pueblo teachers in District 60 vote to go on strike
The bill would allow school districts to seek a court injunction against teacher strikes , according to The Hill . Paul Lundeen said in a statement that he supports better teacher pay, but says strikes aren't productive.Modi to interact with BJP candidates in Karnataka
However, the announcement made by the BJP on its Twitter handle did not go down well with social media. Nominations began on April 17 after a single-phase election to the 224-member assembly was notified. -
Syracuse Fraternity Permanently Expelled for Discriminatory Videos
In response, Theta Tau members said they were roasting a conservative Republican fraternity member and that the video was satire. SU refused to release the video, but The Daily Orange obtained a recording of the video and posted it on its website Wednesday.'I'm being attacked': Hannity responds to media blitz over his properties
In January 2016, Hannity said there were "millions more Americans suffering under this president" partly because of foreclosures. Among the documents the Federal Bureau of Investigation seized from Cohen were details on the real estate investments.Golden State Warriors vs. San Antonio Spurs
They went 12-0 in the West on the way to winning their second NBA Championship, sweeping the San Antonio Spurs along the way. That question was posed to Golden State's Draymond Green , whose response wasn't quite as good as his facial expressions.